A Close Race in Michigan

Those writing President Donald Trump’s political obituary assume that former Vice President Joe Biden will net a key swing state: Michigan. While a Democratic sweep of their 16 electoral votes would reduce Trump’s chances of victory, such an outcome is not predetermined and the state looks increasingly unpredictable.

The Trafalgar Group's Michigan results

Consider the most recent poll from the Trafalgar Group, which has Trump behind Biden by less than a point in the Wolverine State: Biden commands 46.2% of the vote to 45.3% for Trump. 4% are undecided and 4.5% will back a third-party candidate. While Biden nominally leads, the margin of error is 2.95%.

In other words, the Trafalgar Group poll informs us that the state will be closely fought either way. It will either be a Trump state by a narrow margin or a Biden state by a narrow margin. This is consistent with the latest poll from CNBC/Change Research, which has Biden up by two points, but it stands in stark contrast to Biden’s double-digit leads in other surveys compiled by RealClearPolitics.

The Trafalgar Group’s sample of 1,101 was 53.9% female and 46.1% male. This theoretically skews the results toward the Democrats as women are more likely than their male counterparts to support Biden. However, this skew was likely offset by the age distribution of the sample, which is predominantly 50-and-up (a demographic that has proved more favorable for the president).

The Trafalgar Group is a Republican-affiliated pollster. However, just as I am willing to take Public Policy Polling surveys at face value, I value the Trafalgar Group’s record of accuracy more than I discount them for their partisan leanings. In 2016, they were the only pollster cataloged by the RCP average to call Trump’s upset victory in Michigan. The Trafalgar Group had Trump up by two points; he won by 0.3 point.

The takeaway from the most recent Trafalgar Group survey is simple: Individual polls that predict a Biden landslide in Michigan are not the only data points available. It is important to consider them all -- not just the ones that fulfill preconceived notions about the election.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trump Favored in Pennsylvania

Image
The RealClearPolitics polling average in Pennsylvania is Biden +3.7, with polls ranging from Trump +2 (InsiderAdvantage) to Biden +7 (Quinnipiac). I predict that President Donald Trump will narrowly win the state. Consider Muhlenberg College’s most recent poll for the Morning Call , which pegs Biden’s support level at 49% and Trump’s at 44%. 2016 election in PA Consider also that Muhlenberg’s final 2016 poll had Clinton up 48% to 42%, a six-point lead. Trump ended up winning the state by a little less than a point. The cross-tabs tell us why Muhlenberg was wrong: they found Trump only marginally leading males (45% to 43%), whites (49% to 42%), and independents (41% to 38%). The final results for these categories, per CNN exit polls , were 57% to 40%, 56% to 40%, and 48% to 41%, respectively. Thus, I am skeptical of some of the findings from Muhlenberg’s most recent poll, which shows that Trump’s lead is 49% to 43% among men and 52% to 44% among whites. Further, Muhlenberg has Trump
Read more

Ron Johnson Saves Taxpayers at Least $89 Billion

Image
By opposing a $1,200 check to each American and $500 for each dependent, Senator Ron Johnson (R., Wisconsin) pushed Congress toward a $600 check for each American making less than $75,000 and $600 for each dependent. In so doing, Johnson saved the taxpayer at least $89 billion. Ron Johnson ( Milwaukee Journal Sentinel ) Based on my calculations, there are at least 191,400,280 Americans making less than $75,000 a year, as there are 255,200,373 adults and 75% of income earners make less than $75,000 a year. Carrying over that 75% statistic, there are also at least 49,835,000 dependents (as there are 66,447,000 people under 18). These numbers are a bit low, as they yield a sum of 241,235,280—i.e., a cost of $144.74 billion after the Johnson intervention. The actual cost  of the handouts will be $166 billion. Prior to Johnson's intervention, the cost of the $600 checks to people making less than $75,000 a year would have been at least $229.68 billion (191.4 million times $1,200) an
Read more

The Anatomy of a Biased Poll

Image
YouGov, CBS News's pollster of choice, released a poll showing that former Vice President Joe Biden leads President Donald Trump by 10 points: 52% to 42%. Their sample consisted of 957 registered voters with a margin of error of plus/minus 3.6 points. According to YouGov, Trump leads Biden by 10 points (47% to 37%) among independents and by 88 points (93% to 5%) among Republicans. So, why is he behind by 10 points overall? The sample—i.e., the group of people that YouGov polled—was roughly 41% Democratic, 30% Republican, and 27% independent. Compare YouGov's sample to the actual breakdown of the electorate: 41% independent, 31% Democratic, and 26% Republican. YouGov's numbers, when adjusted to fit reality, indicate a much tighter race: 45.9% Biden to 44.4% Trump (my math is below). President Donald Trump The massive over-representation of Democrats in YouGov's sample is a textbook example of why conservatives and impartial observers reflexively discount public-opinion
Read more